Unfair Prejudice Petitions and Derivative Actions – overlapping remedies and striking out – Article by William McCormick KC

Two recent cases have provided clarity on the ability of shareholders to bring claims for unfair prejudice under s.994 Companies Act 2006 (CA 06) even if the prejudice suffered could be the subject of other claims by the shareholders or the company (including a derivative action) against the individual(s) responsible for that prejudice. Given that such petitions almost always plead that the conduct complained of amounted to breaches of various directors’ duties (which are owed not to the shareholders but to the company), and that the relief sought includes (albeit usually as an alternative) permission to bring a derivative claim, the overlap is obvious and the scope for respondents to raise an objection to the form of the proceedings is similarly clear. These cases show how the Courts are likely to approach challenges to the use of s.994 in such situations.

William McCormick KC, instructed by Adam Tudor of Carter Ruck, acted for the Petitioner in Re Chemilines Group Holdings Ltd.

To read the full article, please click here.

To read more about William’s practice, please visit here.

newsletter
Instructing Barristers in Chambers
Contact us to discuss your case
Make a call:
+44 (0)20 7420 9500

Our clerks’ room is open between 8.30am – 6.30pm

Outside of these hours and in cases of an urgency, please contact Paul Bunting on +44 (0) 7971 843023 or Darren Madle on +44 (0) 7769 714399.

C&Ps-Badge-2026
Legal-500-Badge-2026
C&Ps-Badge-2025
Legal-500-Badge-2025
C&Ps-Global-Badge-2025
UK-Bar-Set-Logo-2024-jpg
Leading-Silk-2024-Logo-jpg
Global-2023-CP-Award-e1678899898175
Legal-500-Shortlist-e1678899889419
Chambers-Winner-e1678899876787