Orchard & Anor v Alison Mooney & Ors [2023] UKUT 78 (LC) (03 April 2023)

David Warner appeared in the Estates Gazette: Landlord & Tenant for his successful representation of the appellants. The initial case concerned a water leak in the roof of the building and subsequent disagreement over which party held the repairing obligations. An application was made to the First-tier Tribunal for the appointment of a manager (the first respondent) in February 2019. The FTT dismissed an application by the appellants to discharge the first respondent and return management of the building to the company through with the leaseholders jointly owned the freehold. The appellants appealed, contending that fresh evidence showed that the FTT had been given materially inaccurate evidence, applied an inappropriate test when considering whether to discharge the manager and failed to give sufficient explanation for its decision. The appeal was allowed.

David was instructed directly for the appellants.

Judgment

newsletter
Instructing Barristers in Chambers
Contact us to discuss your case
Make a call:
+44 (0)20 7420 9500

Our clerks’ room is open between 8.30am – 6.30pm

Outside of these hours and in cases of an urgency, please contact Paul Bunting on +44 (0) 7971 843023 or Darren Madle on +44 (0) 7769 714399.

UK-Bar-Set-Logo-2024-jpg
Global-2023-CP-Award-e1678899898175
Chambers-Winner-e1678899876787
Legal-500-Shortlist-e1678899889419
Leading-Silk-2024-Logo-jpg